Enterprise Investment Scheme CGT exemption not available

Enterprise Investment Schem

Enterprise Investment Scheme CGT exemption not available

The Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) is designed to help smaller higher-risk trading companies to raise finance by offering a range of tax reliefs, including Income Tax and Capital Gains Tax (CGT) relief to investors who purchase new shares in those companies.

In a recent Upper Tribunal case, a taxpayer appealed against HMRC’s assertion that he was not entitled to a CGT exemption in respect of an investment under the EIS scheme. The facts of the case were slightly unusual. In January 2005, the taxpayer had invested £50,000 in shares in a company under the EIS. The taxpayer did not claim EIS Income Tax relief because his taxable income for 2004-05 was only £42. In June 2011, the taxpayer sold his shares for £333,200. In submitting his Self-Assessment tax return for 2011-12, the taxpayer did not include any gain in relation to the shares in the return because he understood that the gain was exempt from CGT under the EIS.

The taxpayer made a note on his return to explain why no CGT was payable. An HMRC enquiry followed, which decided that the taxpayer was only entitled to exemption from CGT if he had obtained EIS Income Tax relief on the acquisition of the shares and, as he had not done so, he was liable to CGT on the gain. The First-Tier Tribunal and the Upper Tribunal upon appeal, agreed that however unfairly the legislation had been worded, HRMC was correct that no CGT exemption was available where no claim for EIS Income Tax relief had been made.

The First-Tier Tribunal suggested that the taxpayer make a late claim for Income Tax relief to HMRC, which could solve the taxpayer’s issue. The taxpayer did do but the claim was rejected by HMRC. However, the Upper Tribunal in rejecting the taxpayers appeal issued a strongly worded request for HMRC to re-consider its decision in light of this exceptional case. Whilst the facts of this case are uncommon, it highlights that HMRC can be open to challenge by way of judicial review.

For more information on Enterprise Investment Scheme, Book a Free Consultation

Our Offices

Makesworth Accountants in Harrow

Unit-101, First Floor,
Cervantes House, 5-9 Headstone Road,,
Harrow, London HA1 1PD
United Kingdom (UK)
Phone: 020 7993 8850
Fax: 020 7183 5320
Email: info@makesworth.co.uk

Makesworth Accountants in Central London

63/66 Hatton Garden
Fifth Floor Suite 23,
Central London, London EC1N 8LE
United Kingdom (UK)
Phone: 020 7993 8850
Fax: 020 7183 5320
Email: info@makesworth.co.uk

Makesworth Accountants in Ilford

Balfour Business Centre, Suite B15
390-392 High Road,
Ilford, London IG1 1BF
United Kingdom (UK)
Phone: 020 7993 8850
Fax: 020 7183 5320
Email: info@makesworth.co.uk

Makesworth Accountants in Glasgow

Unit 103, Nasmyth Building, 60 Nasmyth Avenue, Scottish Enterprise
Technology Park,
East Killbridge, Glasgow G75 0QR
United Kingdom (UK)
Phone: 020 7993 8850
Fax: 020 7183 5320
Email: info@makesworth.co.uk

Makesworth Accountants in Barnet

169 High Street,
Barnet, London EN5 5SU
United Kingdom (UK)
Phone: 020 7993 8850
Fax: 020 7183 5320
Email: info@makesworth.co.uk

Proud to be featured in

Happy with our services? Please leave us a Google Review. Click here

Google Review Stars